Alan Lescht & Associates, P.C.
Call 202-536-3315 Se habla espaƱol

South Dakota Supreme Court may decide non-compete case

Our Washington readers may be interested in a non-compete case out of South Dakota which, as headlines point out, tests the limits on how far hospitals can be restricted in their ability to include non-compete agreements in physician contracts.

The case involves a Sanford Health, a hospital in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, who was sued by a former physician employee for wrongful termination, wage discrimination, harassment and retaliation. The physician in the case is a former Sanford Health gastroenterologist. In her complaint, she says that she was fired because she questioned a fellow physician's quality of care. She also claims she was paid less than her male colleagues.

As part of the decision in that case, Judge Doug Hoffman ruled that a non-compete agreement Sanford placed in its standard physician contracts violates state law since it may interfere with the doctor-patient relationship. Under South Dakota law, non-compete agreements may restrict physicians from working within 20 miles of their previous place of employment for up to two years after they leave.

According to Judge Hoffman, non-compete agreements have the potential to create an undue burden for some patients who wish to keep their doctor following a termination and have to drive lengthy distances to see them.

Sanford Health will be seeking to appeal that decision. According to sources, Sanford is likely to attempt a bypass of the circuit court and appeal the decision directly to the State Supreme Court, as the issue is one of public interest. But that can only happen once a final order on the non-compete agreement is issued.

States vary in their approach to non-compete agreements. In some states, there is a strong leaning against such agreements, whereas other states take seek to ensure that the agreement is reasonable.

Source: Argus Leader, "Case tests limits on where doctors work," John Hutt, Sep 5, 2011.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
I have been a litigator for close to 20 years and Alan is most certainly one of the best attorneys I have ever come across.
Mr. Lescht is an excellent Trial Lawyer, He is calm, cool, and collected.
I also appreciated Alan's frankness and his ability to identify what is important and what is not when going through a case like this.
I would highly recommend Alan to anyone who needs an exceptional and incredibly talented Employment Attorney.
Mr. Lescht is an extraordinarily responsive attorney, returning my emails and phone calls within minutes. I would absolutely recommend him to anyone who thinks they may need a lawyer. Definitely incredible work.
I was impressed with his knowledge and professionalism, and I will always be grateful for his guidance.

1050 17th Street NW | Suite 400 | Washington, DC 20036 | Phone: 202-536-3315 | Map & Directions